Tuesday, July 22, 2008



Maus:

  • Spiegelman, Art. (1991). Maus. New York: Pantheon Books a division of Random House, 296 pp.
  • Genre: Graphic Novel; Autobiography
  • Awards: 1990 Max & Moritz Prize, 1992 Pulitzer Prize, 1992 Eisner Award, 1992 Harvey Award, 1993 Los Angeles Times Book Prize for Fiction

Maus is simultaneously Art Spiegelman's autobiography which emphasizes his quest to reconcile with his elderly father, Vladek, and the story of his elderly father's experiences during the Holocaust. Vladek and his wife Anja lived in Poland until the Nazis forced them and their extended family into ghettos and eventually into Aushuwitz. Through skill and luck, both Vladek and Anja come out of the Holocaust alive. The couple then immigrates to New York, where they have Art. Art's childhood is fraught with stresses of living with two Holocaust survivors, both experiencing post traumatic stress. In 1968, Art's mother kills herself and leaves no note. Art and Vladek are emotionally destroyed by the event. Art begins to blame his father for pushing his mother to suicide. Though Art knows his father is not guilty, it takes Vladek explaining his experiences in the Holocaust for Art to understand and forgive his father.

With the use of flashbacks, the setting of the story is constantly in flux between 1970's New York and 1940's Poland/Germany. These flashbacks are the central plot structure of the novel in that they allow Spiegelman to compare his experiences with his elderly father's recollections of his struggles as a young man trying to survive genocide. Spiegelman oscillates between his personal reflections on his father and the stories his father told him in order to understand Vladek as a whole person rather than just a father.

By illustrating the father-son relationship on such a complex level, Spiegelman creates a work that is effective in allowing adolescent readers to more clearly understand their interactions with their parents. Additionally, Spiegelman addresses many ethnic and cultural issues, which expand the book beyond his immediate family. Maus contains invaluable lessons on the destructive nature of bigotry and what it means to survive such persecution. By writing about real events, Spiegelman has created a device for adolescents to vicariously experience emotional contempt for parental figures, the horrific nature of ethnic biases, and the importance of reconciling with the past in order to live a healthy life. Additionally, the first person voice of the story adds a certain intensity in that it creates realistic strife. The narration is too honest and sincere to be taken lightly. It seems that this sincerity will be compelling for adolescents searching for reality in literature.

  • Classroom Use: This book could easily be used as a whole group reading. Its historical significance makes it easily defensible. As well, the graphic novel component alleviates much of the tension which novels may create for nervous readers. The content of the work is also perfect for any small group discussion. This work is of such high quality that it could be worked into the classroom at any level and still have a beneficial effect for all students.
  • Appropriate Age Range: 14 and above. The graphic nature of this book, though being directed at mice not humans, should be approached by readers capable of understanding the significance of the violence in the story. Additionally, many of the English/German linguistic colloquial merges would be difficult for younger readers to maneuver.

Maus was an extremely moving read for me. Its reflections on themes such as guilt, survival, family, and desperation were thought provoking and inspiring. The confessional style of Spiegelman's narration made the words and illustrations soul wrenching. He was successful in making the reader feel what he and his father felt.

Brian Lee

3 comments:

katylovesbooks said...

Brian,
I really appreciate this post. I struggle with graphic novels, even though I think they would be really important in a classroom, especially for struggling readers. The themes of this book seem so important. I hope I can read it some day, and maybe I can learn to appreciate and understand the immense artistry and talent a book like this possesses. Thank you so much for your post! See you tomorrow!

Grace said...

I know I talked to you in class about this but I wanted to share with other readers of your lovely blog. When I was doing my observation, one class (9th grade) was reading Night by Elie Wiesel. They had an education edition of the book and there was a connections section in the back. There was a segment of this graphic novel there for readers. I also wanted to say that evidently the graphic novel genre is further developed than I thought it was. I had just assumed that the standard Japanese/ Comic strip graphic novel was all that was out there. Obviously, there is much more. Great selection, I appreciate it and will hopefully add it to my classroom library some day.

Brittany said...

Brian,

I read MAUS, too, and loved it something wicked. You make a lot of good points in your blog, especially about the effectiveness of the multi-layered narrative and about the sincerity of the story as presented from Vladek's POV. I found it interesting that in one frame, Spiegelman (the character) expresses concern that he depicts his father too stereotypically. I actually thought just the opposite; Vladek came across for me as a very full character. I also think the metanarrative aspect of Spiegelman writing about Spiegelman writing the book was an interesting addition. I don't know if you've ever seen the movie ADAPTATION (Nicholas Cage, Chris Cooper, Meryl Streep), but that's what this aspect of MAUS reminded me of. Anyway, thanks for the post. I was going to talk about this book for my presentation, but you beat me to it. At least I can be satisfied that you'll do it justice :)